Former Michigan quarterback J.J. McCarthy is now a Minnesota Viking. The was a lot of speculation of where McCarthy would end up. Some thought the Vikings would trade up to grab McCarthy, others thought the Giants would take him at six, and a few thought he could drop the 12 and be taken by the Broncos.
It was the Vikings that landed the National Champion quarterback who led his team to a 15-0 season in 2023. Technically Minnesota did trade up to get McCarthy, but they only traded up one pick in front of the Jets to grab him with the 10th pick.
McCarthy was the fifth quarterback to be taken in the first round. The first three taken were expected with Caleb Wiliams going first to the Bear, Jayden Daniels to the Commanders, and Drake Maye to the Patriots. However, everyone thought McCarthy would have been the next QB off the board, but the Falcons surprised everyone by taking the quarterback McCarthy faced in the National Championship Michael Penix Jr. with the eight pick.
However, it seems like this is the best landing spot for McCarthy for many reasons and everyone, both fans and analysts alike, believes so too. Here are some of the best reactions and takes about McCarthy being drafted by the Minnesota Vikings.
Newly drafted #Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy got a phone call from Wayne Gretzky tonight while on a Zoom call with local media.
โ Alec Ausmus (@A_TwiceKSTP) April 26, 2024
J.J. truly loves hockey, makes complete sense he ended up in Minnesota! pic.twitter.com/H3TJwpeev1
Minnesota and hockey go together like peanut butter and jelly. It has come out that McCarthy is a huge hockey fan, but he is a fan of the Chicago Blackhawks, so Minnesota Wild fans will probably try to fix that problem. However, this now seems like even more of a perfect fit for McCarthy. Oh and he got a call from Wayne Gretzky, what a night for the kid.
If you're a Viking fan and a Drake Maye guy or gal (me), ya just kinda gotta ask yourself what you'd rather have.
โ Dustin Baker (@DustBaker) April 26, 2024
Option 1 โ
๐ Drake Maye
Option 2 โ
๐ J.J. McCarthy
๐ Dallas Turner
๐ 2025 1st-Rounder
๐ Whatever Else NE Wanted
Imagine getting the quarterback you wanted all along and not having to give up your entire future for him. Oh, wait, the Vikings did just that! Minnesota was able to keep both of their first-round picks and still got McCarthy, the guy they think is going to do it all for them without having to trade away any future first-round picks or players. Seems like a good deal to me.
J.J. McCarthyโs reaction to getting the call from the Vikings #SKOL pic.twitter.com/z0Nd3C4zA0
โ Patrick Siepman (@PatSieps) April 26, 2024
Looks like McCarthy already has the Skol clap down. There is obviously excitement in simply getting drafted especially in the first round, but there is clear excitement and joy in him going to the Vikings.
Imma take a shot hereโฆ
โ Tyler Schmidt (@tschmidt2512) April 26, 2024
J.J McCarthy wins offensive rookie of the year
Could we see rookie quarterbacks in Offensive Rookie of the Year in back-to-back seasons? It is possible, but he will have a lot of competition with the number of quarterbacks taken in the first round. However, this seems like the best fit out of all of them.
J.J. McCarthy will have a better season than Caleb Williams you heard it here first ๐ค
โ ๏ธ๏ธ๏ธ๐ (@_Voney_) April 26, 2024
Definitely a hot take, but thoughts? Williams has quite the setup around him in Chicago, but can their defense hold up the offense? McCarthy might feel more secure with the better defense and ultimately have the better season.
You know the best thing about drafting J.J. McCarthy?
โ jason (@spardisjx) April 26, 2024
We don't have to sweat the QB class next year. At all.
Thank God ๐ฎโ๐จ
This was the year of quarterbacks and there is no question about it. The Vikings have a guy for the future barring anything crazy happening.
If all goes well, the NFC North is gonna be incredibly fun for a long time.
โ Jacob Infante (@jacobinfante24) April 26, 2024
Caleb Williams, Jordan Love & J.J. McCarthy are all gifted, young QBs. Jared Goff is rock solid and likely has years of good play left.
Could have some fun shootouts these next few years.
Two rookies and two veterans in the division with each team making lots of noise in free agency. Could the NFC North be the best division in the NFL next season?
Came out really high on J.J. McCarthy in the first run of Dynasty rankings. Great system, incredible weapons, not in New England, doesn't even turn 22 until 2025. QB3 for me in rookie drafts.
โ Heath Cummings (@heathcummingssr) April 26, 2024
McCarthy might have just been drafted into the best-set system out of all the rookie quarterbacks taken in the first round. The weapons he has at his disposal with Justin Jefferson, Jordan Addison, T.J. Hockenson, and Aaron Jones give him a great opportunity to be as successful as possible.
Really, really high praise here from Bill Belichick on Vikings QB J.J. McCarthy: โHe just makes good decisions.โ pic.twitter.com/DwS3dmiNtT
โ Alec Lewis (@alec_lewis) April 26, 2024
Bill Belichick doesn't give out a lot of praise, especially to rookie quarterbacks, so this is big.
*Me when the Vikings called everyone's bluff and got J.J. McCarthy at 10 while keeping 23.
โ 7-10/46-36 (@TheSkolWarrior) April 26, 2024
*Me when the Vikings traded up to 17 to get Dallas Turner.
*Me when the Vikings got these two players and kept 2025 1st.#SKOL pic.twitter.com/mQ6F1IDUdt
Congratulations Vikings fans, you had one heck of a night in round one without giving up anything for the future and keeping your second first-round pick. The Vikings might have just gained a few Michigan fans with the McCarthy pick.