It didn't take nine or 10 games to realize that Kyle Whittingham shouldn't be the Michigan football head coach.
Anyone honest with themselves could tell after the first game that something was off. Whittingham was hired to do a job and he wasn't up to it.
Western Michigan nearly beat the Wolverines as a four-touchdown underdog. The Wolverines needed that final second and a Hail Mary to win the game.
Michigan scored on the first drive of the season. That's where the good vibes ended for the offense. Jason Beck used way too much Rhino, confused his own offensive line, and didn't do anything to help his quarterbacks or running backs.
It was a disaster. What was even more of a disaster was Whittingham calling out play calls against Western, Iowa, and Indiana after the fact, as if he were powerless to stop them.
Two days after the Indiana game, Michigan announced a search for a national athletic director. Trev Alberts was hired this week, according to reports. Some have speculated that he will clean house. Some have suggested he could give Whittingham another season.
That seems like folly to me. Whittingham is washed up. It was apparent by the first game, and there hasn't been a single sign to the contrary. A new article by The Athletic shows how little support there is for Whittingham; as Bruce Feldman and Austin Meek write, players were counting the days until the end of the season.
"Two Michigan parents described a grim scene before Michigan’s game against Michigan State as players counted down the days until the season ended and they could enter the portal. The next day, Michigan stumbled through a listless loss to a bitter rival that had been winless in the Big Ten under its own first-year coach."
The Athletic also explained why the Rhino package was such a terrible idea, yet Whittingham approved it and allowed it to continue.
"The reliance on the rhino meant Michigan was blocking Big Ten edge rushers with a converted defensive tackle or a backup guard, not the tackles recruited for that purpose. A stockpile of versatile tight ends recruited by Harbaugh and Moore went largely unused. If Buchanan and Marsh couldn’t get open, Beck’s offense didn’t provide many other options for Michigan’s quarterbacks."
Another Big Ten coach said he hopes Whittingham gets another season.
“Those guys are underachieving,” said the coach. “I’ve seen those backs running better than they are now. The O-line has underachieved. I’m hoping they give (Whittingham) another year to make up some ground on them.”
Can Kyle Whittingham save his job?
Saturday's game will be interesting. Bob Chesney, the UCLA head coach and maybe the closest thing to Curt Cignetti, will be coaching the Bruins. He has also been talked about as a top candidate for Michigan.
Michigan is a 3.5-point underdog. It feels like there is a chance to beat the fourth-ranked Bruins. Who knows what will happen against Ohio State, but it makes you wonder: if Whittingham wins both games would that buy him a second season?
Or is he one-and-done regardless? If that were the case, one would think he'd be fired already, except Michigan didn't have an athletic director, even in waiting, until earlier this week. It's hard to know when Alberts can start exercising his authority. He can evaluate, but if he wanted to fire Kyle Whittingham Saturday, could he do it?
Saturday's game will be interesting. The seniors deserve to go out with a win. They deserved better than that this season, but whatever the result, Michigan has to make sure it doesn't get stuck not seeing the big picture.

